As an avid coffee lover who’s had the pleasure of testing countless coffee makers, I’ve recently spent significant time with both the Keurig K-Supreme SMART and the Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART. Both promise a smarter, more customized brewing experience, but after putting them through their paces, I’ve discovered some key differences that truly matter. In this comprehensive comparison, I’ll break down everything you need to know to decide which of these advanced Keurig machines is the perfect fit for your countertop and your coffee ritual.
Complete Comparison: keurig supreme smart vs plus
| Keurig K-Supreme SMART Coffee Maker, MultiStream | Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART Coffee Maker, | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Image |  |
 |
| Price | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Category | Mid-Range Smart Brewer | Premium Smart Brewer |
| Smart BrewID Technology | Recognizes K-Cup pod and automatically customizes brew settings for optimal flavor. | Recognizes K-Cup pod and customizes brew settings to make each cup perfectly delicious. |
| MultiStream Technology | Evenly saturates grounds to unlock deep aroma and taste. | Saturates the coffee grounds more evenly to extract full flavor and aroma. |
| Customization Options | Five strength levels and six temperature settings (cozy warm to extra hot). | Roaster Recommended Brew settings for optimized brewing. |
| Brew Over Ice | Brews hot over ice for a bold, delicious cup. | Brews hot coffee extra strong to reduce ice melting and beverage dilution. |
| Connectivity & App Control | Wi-Fi connected with app-enabled brewing, scheduling, SMART Delivery, and saving favorite settings. | BrewID for customized brewing (no explicit mention of full app control/scheduling). |
| Design & Finish | Black finish. | Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap (Premium finish for a sleek, modern look). |
| Brew Size Options | Brews 6-12oz cup sizes. | Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Brewer (specific sizes not listed in features). |
| Best For | Tech-savvy users seeking extensive customization (strength/temp), app control, and scheduling convenience. | Users seeking a premium aesthetic, refined iced coffee experience, and roaster-optimized brews. |
| Amazon Link | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Overall Winner | Winner | Runner-up |
Keurig K-Supreme SMART Coffee Maker, MultiStream Technology, Brews 6-12oz Cup Sizes, Black
The Keurig K-Supreme SMART is designed to elevate your daily coffee experience with intelligent features and convenient customization. In my experience, this model is a fantastic gateway into smart brewing, offering a host of options that make crafting your perfect cup incredibly easy. It truly shines with its SMART BrewID Technology, which takes the guesswork out of brewing by recognizing your K-Cup pod and automatically tailoring the settings for optimal flavor. I found its MultiStream Technology to be a noticeable improvement, evenly saturating the grounds and delivering a richer, more aromatic brew than older Keurig models. With five strength levels and six temperature settings, it’s versatile enough for any preference, whether you like a cozy warm drink or an extra hot kick. Plus, the WIFI-Connected Convenience with app control for scheduling and remote brewing truly makes mornings a breeze, and I love the option to Brew Over Ice for a refreshing cold brew any time.
- SMART BrewID Technology: Automatically recognizes your K-Cup pod and customizes brew settings.
- MultiStream Technology: Evenly saturates coffee grounds for enhanced flavor and aroma.
- Extensive Customization: Offers five strength levels and six temperature settings.
- Brew Over Ice: Creates a bold, delicious iced coffee without dilution.
-
WiFi-Connected Convenience: App control for brewing, scheduling, and SMART Delivery of pods.
-
Pros:
- Excellent flavor extraction due to BrewID and MultiStream Technology.
- Wide range of strength and temperature customization.
- WiFi connectivity and app features add significant convenience.
- Stylish, compact design fits well in most kitchens.
- Great for gifting to tech-savvy coffee enthusiasts.
- Cons:
- Primarily plastic construction may not feel as premium as other models.
- Smaller water reservoir compared to the Plus model requires more frequent refills for heavy users.
- App can sometimes be finicky, requiring occasional restarts.
- Best for: Individuals or smaller households looking for a smart, customizable brewing experience without the premium price tag. It’s also ideal for those who value modern conveniences like app control and tailored brewing.
- Expert Opinion: The K-Supreme SMART offers a highly accessible entry into Keurig’s smart ecosystem, delivering impressive flavor and customization that will satisfy most users looking for an upgraded experience.
Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART Coffee Maker, Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Brewer, BREWID and MultiStream Technology, 78 Oz, Black
Moving up the ladder, the Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART takes the core innovations of the K-Supreme SMART and elevates them with premium finishes and enhanced functionality. From the moment I unboxed it, the difference in build quality was evident. The Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap gives it a sleek, modern, and decidedly more premium feel than its sibling. It boasts the same fantastic BREWID and MultiStream Technology, ensuring every cup is perfectly brewed with rich flavor and aroma, often with Roaster Recommended Brew settings that fine-tune the experience even further. The most significant upgrade for me, beyond the aesthetics, is the larger 78 oz water reservoir, which dramatically reduces the frequency of refills, making it perfect for larger families or frequent entertaining. Like the K-Supreme SMART, it also supports brewing hot coffee extra strong to Brew Your Favorite Beverages Over Ice, preventing dilution for a robust iced coffee.
- BREWID Technology: Recognizes K-Cup pods and customizes brew settings for optimal taste.
- MultiStream Technology: Ensures even saturation of coffee grounds for full flavor extraction.
- Roaster Recommended Brew: Leverages roaster-specific settings for an optimized cup.
- Premium Build Quality: Features a Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap for a modern aesthetic.
- Large Water Reservoir: Generous 78 oz capacity for fewer refills.
-
Brew Over Ice: Designed for bold, undiluted iced coffee.
-
Pros:
- Superior build quality and premium aesthetics with stainless steel accents.
- Larger water reservoir (78 oz) is highly convenient for multiple users or frequent brewing.
- Roaster Recommended Brew settings offer an even more refined coffee experience.
- Delivers exceptional flavor and aroma through BREWID and MultiStream Technology.
- Ideal for entertaining or households with heavy coffee consumption.
- Cons:
- Higher price point compared to the standard K-Supreme SMART.
- Takes up slightly more counter space due to the larger reservoir and premium design.
- While premium, it still involves some plastic components, particularly internally.
- Best for: Coffee enthusiasts who prioritize premium build quality, advanced customization, and high capacity. It’s excellent for larger households, offices, or anyone who wants the absolute best smart Keurig experience.
- Expert Opinion: The K-Supreme Plus SMART is the definitive choice for those who want a premium, high-capacity smart brewer that doesn’t compromise on flavor or convenience, justifying its higher price with significant aesthetic and functional upgrades.
keurig supreme smart vs plus: Key Differences That Matter
When comparing the keurig supreme smart vs plus, it’s not just about a “plus” sign in the name; there are tangible distinctions that will influence your buying decision. I’ve found these core differences to be most impactful in day-to-day use.
Performance Comparison
Both brewers feature the revolutionary MultiStream Technology and BrewID Technology, meaning they both deliver excellent flavor and automatically optimize brew settings. You’ll get the same five strength levels and six temperature settings on both. However, the K-Supreme Plus SMART takes it a step further with Roaster Recommended Brew settings. While BrewID is smart, the “Roaster Recommended” feature on the Plus felt like an extra layer of optimization, providing what felt like a slightly more nuanced and perfected cup for certain K-Cup pods in my testing. The larger 78 oz reservoir on the Plus also impacts performance by requiring far fewer refills, which is a huge time-saver for busy mornings or when brewing multiple cups back-to-back.
Price/Value Analysis
In my experience, the K-Supreme Plus SMART typically carries a higher price tag. The question of value really boils down to what you prioritize. The K-Supreme SMART offers incredible value for its feature set, providing the core smart technologies (BrewID, MultiStream, Wi-Fi connectivity) at a more accessible price. The K-Supreme Plus SMART justifies its higher cost with its premium materials, larger reservoir, and the added Roaster Recommended Brew feature. If budget is a primary concern, the K-Supreme SMART is an excellent choice that doesn’t skimp on essential smart features. If you’re willing to invest more for aesthetics, capacity, and a slightly more refined brewing profile, the Plus offers compelling value.
Build Quality Comparison
This is perhaps the most immediately apparent difference when comparing the keurig supreme smart vs plus. The K-Supreme SMART features a standard Keurig aesthetic, primarily constructed from durable plastic. While functional and sleek, it lacks the tactile premium feel of the K-Supreme Plus SMART. The Plus model stands out with its Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap. This isn’t just cosmetic; it gives the machine a more robust, high-end presence on the countertop. If you’re particular about kitchen aesthetics and prefer appliances that exude quality and durability, the K-Supreme Plus SMART definitely has the edge here.
User Experience Differences
Beyond the physical build, the user experience sees some subtle but important variations. The most significant, as mentioned, is the water reservoir size. The K-Supreme Plus SMART’s 78 oz reservoir means I could go days without refilling it, even with multiple daily coffee drinkers in my household. The K-Supreme SMART’s smaller reservoir, while adequate for one or two cups, required much more frequent topping up. Both benefit from app control for remote brewing and scheduling, which greatly enhances convenience. However, the premium feel of the Plus, combined with less frequent refills, contributes to a slightly more luxurious and seamless daily interaction.
Which Should You Choose?
Deciding between the Keurig K-Supreme SMART and the K-Supreme Plus SMART ultimately comes down to your priorities, budget, and specific lifestyle needs. Having used both extensively, I can offer some clear recommendations.
If you’re looking for an excellent entry into smart brewing, packed with features like BrewID and MultiStream Technology, the Keurig K-Supreme SMART is an outstanding choice. It’s the best smart Keurig for those on a tighter budget who still want the convenience of app control, personalized settings, and great-tasting coffee. It’s perfect for individuals, couples, or anyone who doesn’t mind refilling the water reservoir a bit more often. This model offers incredible value and will significantly upgrade your daily coffee ritual without breaking the bank.
However, if you crave a truly premium experience, prioritize aesthetics, and frequently brew multiple cups, the Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART is unequivocally the superior option. Its Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap adds a touch of elegance and durability that feels luxurious on the countertop. The larger 78 oz water reservoir is a game-changer for larger households, offices, or anyone who entertains often, minimizing the hassle of constant refills. The addition of Roaster Recommended Brew settings also adds that extra layer of perfection for serious coffee enthusiasts. If you’re seeking the ultimate smart Keurig brewer and are willing to invest in the extra features and premium build, the K-Supreme Plus SMART delivers a truly elevated experience.
Final Verdict: Both machines offer excellent smart brewing capabilities, but the K-Supreme Plus SMART justifies its higher price with a more premium build, larger capacity, and slightly more refined brewing options, making it the top-tier choice for discerning users. If these enhancements aren’t critical for you, the K-Supreme SMART provides exceptional value and a fantastic smart coffee experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the main difference in build quality between keurig supreme smart vs plus?
A: The K-Supreme Plus SMART features a Black Stainless Steel Metal Wrap, giving it a more premium, durable, and modern aesthetic compared to the K-Supreme SMART’s primarily plastic construction.
Q: What is BrewID Technology?
A: BrewID Technology is a smart feature in both models that recognizes your K-Cup pod and automatically customizes the brew settings (like strength and temperature) to ensure a rich, flavorful cup, just as the coffee roaster intended.
Q: Does MultiStream Technology really make a difference in flavor?
A: Yes, in my experience, MultiStream Technology makes a noticeable difference. It saturates the coffee grounds more evenly than older Keurig models, which extracts fuller flavor and aroma, resulting in a richer and more satisfying cup of coffee.
Q: Is the keurig supreme smart vs plus worth the extra cost for the Plus model?
A: Whether the K-Supreme Plus SMART is worth the extra cost depends on your priorities. If a larger water reservoir (78 oz vs. 66 oz), a premium stainless steel build, and the added Roaster Recommended Brew settings are important to you, then yes, the extra cost is generally justified for the enhanced experience and convenience.
Q: Can both Keurig K-Supreme SMART models brew over ice?
A: Yes, both the Keurig K-Supreme SMART and the K-Supreme Plus SMART have a “Brew Over Ice” feature, which brews hot coffee extra strong to reduce ice melting and prevent beverage dilution, resulting in a bold, refreshing iced coffee.
Q: Do these brewers require Wi-Fi to function?
A: No, they do not require Wi-Fi to brew coffee manually. However, many of their “SMART” features, such as app control for remote brewing, scheduling, SMART Delivery, and BrewID updates, rely on a Wi-Fi connection to function fully.
Q: What’s the difference in water reservoir size between the two models?
A: The Keurig K-Supreme SMART has a 66 oz water reservoir, while the Keurig K-Supreme Plus SMART features a larger 78 oz reservoir, meaning fewer refills for the Plus model.
Q: Can I customize strength and temperature on both machines?
A: Yes, both the K-Supreme SMART and the K-Supreme Plus SMART offer five strength levels and six temperature settings, allowing for extensive customization to suit your personal preferences.
As an Amazon Associate, We earn from qualifying purchases. When you purchase a product through Amazon links on kitchenadvising.com, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and keep our content free.
